Russell Westbrook or
James Harden? Or, alternatively,
LeBron James or
Kawhi Leonard?
From win shares to RPM, NBA player value metrics were designed to help inform our discussion about awards such as this year's fascinating MVP race. Yet it can be tricky to navigate the alphabet soup of various metrics to determine what advanced stats really tell us about the players involved.
Let's take a look at how I would rank the top MVP candidates, based on five important metrics:
BPM:
far and away the best since 1973-74, the first season for which the stat was calculated. LeBron James' 2008-09 season is next at plus-13.0, and there's a larger gap between Westbrook and James than there is between the No. 2 and No. 14 seasons all time.
Based on BPM, Westbrook is on pace for 12.4 VORP, which would surpass
Michael Jordan's record of
12.0 in 1988-89.
What it means: Frankly, Westbrook's season has broken BPM, which is not quite as flattering to him as it sounds.
To improve the quality of the rating for most players, BPM uses interaction effects that multiply a player's assist percentage by his usage rate and his rebound percentage. As you might guess, Westbrook's season is off the charts historically by both measures.
Here's the leaderboard for assist percentage multiplied by usage rate back through 1977-78, the first season the NBA tracked player turnovers:
Win shares (Basketball-Reference.com)[/paste:font]
Rudy Gobert of the
Utah Jazz is second to Harden with 13.9 win shares.) Those factors work against Westbrook, who ranks fifth in the league, by far his lowest ranking in any common value stat.
Win shares also don't factor in the key concept of replacement level, so they tend to reward minutes played, where Harden leads the league, more than productivity.
EWA (based on PER)
Kevin Durantand
Anthony Davis.
WARP
RPM wins[/paste:font]
per NBA.com/Stats, James leads the league in RPM wins even though his box-score statistics have not been as strong as those of the other MVP contenders.
Who's in, who's out of 2017 NBA draft?
Chad Ford provides the latest intel on which players are entering the 2017 NBA draft and which of them are staying put.
It's possible, though, that Westbrook will pass him for the top spot by the end of the season, particularly if James is rested down the stretch.
RPM is relatively low on Harden's candidacy because the Rockets haven't declined much with him on the bench; they still outscore opponents by 4.5 points per 100 possessions
when Harden rests. In particular, Houston defends better without Harden, so his minus-1.7 defensive rating in RPM is the lowest among the MVP candidates by a wide margin. Westbrook rates minus-0.4 points per 100 possessions on defense, which is better than it sounds, because guards are typically worse defensively than frontcourt players.
Leonard's defensive RPM (plus-0.9) has declined dramatically from last year's plus-3.9 mark.
As I've discussed previously, opponent 3-point shooting explains a lot of why the Spurs have defended better with Leonard on the bench. Subsequently, Bo Schwartz Madsen of Nylon Calculus found that
this effect was larger for Leonard than anyone else in the league. If Leonard's defensive RPM was about 3.3 or better, he'd be leading the NBA in RPM wins, so there's a case to be made for him here, too.
It's intriguing that
Westbrook and
Harden have also seen opponents shoot 3s worse against their teams while they're on the bench, though the effect isn't nearly as large as with Leonard. Cavaliers opponents have shot better from 3
with James on the bench.
Any of the top four candidates has a good MVP case depending on the metrics you use. Soobum Im/USA TODAY Sports
Summing up the MVP race by advanced stats
Depending on your metric of choice and assumptions, you can use advanced stats to make a case for any of the four leading contenders, so be careful to avoid cherry-picking in favor of your candidate.
After looking at all these stats, I find it useful to consider players in terms of their impact per 100 possessions at both ends of the court. BPM, RPM and WARP are all similar in terms of how they estimate this impact, and here's how the MVP candidates compare.
Offensive Impact Per 100 Possessions
PLAYERRPMBPMWARPESTIMATE
Russell Westbrook10.66.88.99
James Harden8.66.77.98.5
LeBron James6.65.86.56.5
Kawhi Leonard6.45.36.26.3
Don't flatten the difference in skills by saying all four MVP candidates have been great offensively. It's clear by all three metrics that Harden and Westbrook have been the best offensive players because of how much offense they create for themselves and their teammates. Based on these, my best guess is that Westbrook has a small edge on Harden, with James and Leonard two to three points per 100 possessions behind.
Defensive Impact Per 100 Possessions
PLAYERRPMBPMWARPESTIMATE
Kawhi Leonard0.91.52.12
LeBron James1.21.60.81
Russell Westbrook-0.44.72.0-0.5
James Harden-1.71.50.7-1.5
Defense is tougher to measure statistically, but I'm inclined to consider RPM the most telling metric for Harden and Westbrook, because my scouting suggests their box-score stats overvalue them defensively. Because of the 3-point effect, I think box-score stats actually do better with Leonard, and I'm a little more skeptical of James' regular-season defense than some of the metrics suggest.
Combining those two guesses with minutes played would yield the following wins above replacement based on my estimate of replacement level (about 2.6 points worse than league average per 100 possessions).
Wins Above Replacement
PLAYEROFFENSEDEFENSETOTALWAR
Russell Westbrook9.0-0.58.518.4
LeBron James6.517.517.2
James Harden8.5-1.57.016.9
Kawhi Leonard6.328.316.3
Even though Leonard rates second to Westbrook on a per-possession basis in my subjective evaluation, his lower minutes total relegates him to fourth in my MVP rankings. Meanwhile, Harden's defensive disadvantage relative to James drops him to third with Westbrook comfortably leading the other contenders in terms of wins above replacement.
To me, the most valuable player is the one who adds the most wins to his team's bottom line, and that's why after consulting the advanced stats, Westbrook would be my MVP.
My top four:
1. Russell Westbrook
2. LeBron James
3. James Harden
4. Kawhi Leonard
