kevin02
Gold Star Member
- Joined
- Jul 5, 2013
- Messages
- 869
- Reaction score
- 1,110
- Points
- 93
Instead of putting the first few picks through the lottery and letting all the other teams fall into place, what if they divided it into tiers. Now the obvious issue would be that teams would start tanking to get into the next tier but here's how you could avoid that:
__________________
The Top 3 Lottery
Each tier would receive one top 3 pick. This would be determined in an initial lottery drawing where, starting with the 1st pick, each tier has an equal chance of receiving it. This is repeated 3 times until each tier has been assigned it's top three pick.
__________________
The Tier Lottery
From this point, an additional drawing takes place in each of the three tiers where each team has an equal shot at attaining their groups assigned top 3 pick. Once a team has been selected, the other teams all fall into place based on record. An example of how this works can be seen in the table below.
__________________
Teams: Worst Record - T1 - T2 - T3 - T4 - T5 - T6 - T7 - T8 - T9 - T10 - T11 - T12 - T13 - T14 - Best Record
__________________
Tier 1
Team | Top 3 Odds | Other Picks
T1 | 25% | [4]
T2 | 25% | [4,5]
T3 | 25% | [5,6]
T4 | 25% | [6]
__________________
Tier 2
Team | Top 3 Odds | Other Picks
T5 | 20% | [7]
T6 | 20% | [7,8]
T7 | 20% | [8,9]
T8 | 20% | [9,10]
T9 | 20% | [10]
__________________
Tier 3
Team | Top 3 Odds | Other Picks
T10| 20% | [11]
T11| 20% | [11,12]
T12| 20% | [12,13]
T13| 20% | [13,14]
T14| 20% | [14]
__________________
Why this works
Every team in the lottery, regardless of their record, is guaranteed at least a 20% chance at a top three pick. While in other draft lottery proposals this could lead to an unbalanced league where the bad teams are unable to improve, in this case, every team is also promised a pick no worse than 3 spots lower then where they finished in the standings.
If you're a team performing below expectations in tier 2, then maybe it still sounds appealing to drop down to tier 1 by resting your best players down the stretch. While this may still be a valid strategy since it improves your odds of a top 3 pick by 5% and also improves your worst case scenario, it's less likely a GM would feel pressured into doing this because of the possibility that their tier could end up with the better top 3 pick. This becomes even more of a consideration when the upcoming draft has a single generational talent. Why bother *Riggin' for Wiggins* when each tier has an equal one and three chance of obtaining him anyways.
Finally, this solution also help solve the problem of small market teams stuck in mediocrity having no means of getting better. One of those teams each year would have the opportunity to draft a top 3 player and potentially take the next step. This of course could still result in those same teams tanking to fall out of the playoffs to give themselves a shot at that pick. However, if your a team fighting for spots T13 through T15, it would be a much harder sell to the players and the fan base to start resting players down the stretch for just a 1 in 5 chance of getting the pick. Especially when the alternative in this case is the 13th or 14th pick.
__________________
The Top 3 Lottery
Each tier would receive one top 3 pick. This would be determined in an initial lottery drawing where, starting with the 1st pick, each tier has an equal chance of receiving it. This is repeated 3 times until each tier has been assigned it's top three pick.
__________________
The Tier Lottery
From this point, an additional drawing takes place in each of the three tiers where each team has an equal shot at attaining their groups assigned top 3 pick. Once a team has been selected, the other teams all fall into place based on record. An example of how this works can be seen in the table below.
__________________
Teams: Worst Record - T1 - T2 - T3 - T4 - T5 - T6 - T7 - T8 - T9 - T10 - T11 - T12 - T13 - T14 - Best Record
__________________
Tier 1
Team | Top 3 Odds | Other Picks
T1 | 25% | [4]
T2 | 25% | [4,5]
T3 | 25% | [5,6]
T4 | 25% | [6]
__________________
Tier 2
Team | Top 3 Odds | Other Picks
T5 | 20% | [7]
T6 | 20% | [7,8]
T7 | 20% | [8,9]
T8 | 20% | [9,10]
T9 | 20% | [10]
__________________
Tier 3
Team | Top 3 Odds | Other Picks
T10| 20% | [11]
T11| 20% | [11,12]
T12| 20% | [12,13]
T13| 20% | [13,14]
T14| 20% | [14]
__________________
Why this works
Every team in the lottery, regardless of their record, is guaranteed at least a 20% chance at a top three pick. While in other draft lottery proposals this could lead to an unbalanced league where the bad teams are unable to improve, in this case, every team is also promised a pick no worse than 3 spots lower then where they finished in the standings.
If you're a team performing below expectations in tier 2, then maybe it still sounds appealing to drop down to tier 1 by resting your best players down the stretch. While this may still be a valid strategy since it improves your odds of a top 3 pick by 5% and also improves your worst case scenario, it's less likely a GM would feel pressured into doing this because of the possibility that their tier could end up with the better top 3 pick. This becomes even more of a consideration when the upcoming draft has a single generational talent. Why bother *Riggin' for Wiggins* when each tier has an equal one and three chance of obtaining him anyways.
Finally, this solution also help solve the problem of small market teams stuck in mediocrity having no means of getting better. One of those teams each year would have the opportunity to draft a top 3 player and potentially take the next step. This of course could still result in those same teams tanking to fall out of the playoffs to give themselves a shot at that pick. However, if your a team fighting for spots T13 through T15, it would be a much harder sell to the players and the fan base to start resting players down the stretch for just a 1 in 5 chance of getting the pick. Especially when the alternative in this case is the 13th or 14th pick.