Should I accept this trade?

[DFX]

So I just got offered a trade.

He's offering me:

Miles Austin
Michael Turner
Eric Decker

For:
Dez Bryant
Adrian Peterson

My current starters are:

QB: Matt Schaub
RB: LeSean McCoy
RB: Adrian Peterson
WR: Dez Bryant
WR: Nate Washington
TE: Jimmy Graham

K: John Kasay

DB: Tyvon Branch
DL: Charles Johnson
LB: Patrick Willis

Bench:
Eli Manning
Deion Branch
Julio Jones
Owen Daniels
LaDainian Tomlinson
AJ Hawk

I really don't want to break up my dynamic duo at running back. However, my group of receivers is a pile of hot garbage. I'm on the fence right now and am really leaning towards rejecting the offer as the receivers he's offering just aren't that good, but I'm just not sure.

 

[dano_24_26]

No. Tebow gonna be throwing to decker and dez and miles is a toss up imo

 

[SixPACK]

I wouldn't touch that at all. You are right, why break up your awesome RB combo for an overrated RB, a piece of shit WR and basically the same person (Austin/Bryant)

Reject and tell him to fuck off.

 

[Man Called X]

I give up Ahmad Bradshaw and get Cam Newton.

Romo is my starting QB, Ahdmad and McCoy my studs, followed by Beanie Wells and DeMarco Murray who had a big game for the Cowboys with. Is the hit on Bradsaw on the upgrade Newton worth it?

My WRs are Darrius Heywood-Beys, Greg Jennings, Dez Bryant, and Greg Little lol.

TE. Tony Gonzalez, who I need to get a bye week starter for him.

I'm thinking a strongly QB and a solid receiver should help solidify my team?

 

[CHEECHREBORN]

I give up Ahmad Bradshaw and get Cam Newton.

Romo is my starting QB, Ahdmad and McCoy my studs, followed by Beanie Wells and DeMarco Murray who had a big game for the Cowboys with. Is the hit on Bradsaw on the upgrade Newton worth it?

My WRs are Darrius Heywood-Beys, Greg Jennings, Dez Bryant, and Greg Little lol.

TE. Tony Gonzalez, who I need to get a bye week starter for him.

I'm thinking a strongly QB and a solid receiver should help solidify my team?

There is ZERO chance that DeMarco Murray puts up anywhere near the numbers that he did on Sunday for the rest of the season. He put up those numbers against one of the worst teams in the league. Romo already had his bye so you don't actually need another QB. I think Newton is an upgrade over Romo, but if you make that trade then you need to move romo for a different RB or WR and I doubt that you'd get a RB as good as Bradshaw back

 

[cavsrook25]

I was just offered Chris Johnson and Matt Ryan for Matthew Stafford. I have been using Cam Newton as my starting QB. My RBs are Beanie Wells, Ray Rice, Peyton Hillis and Shonn Greene. I know Johnson has been a bust so far, but he is still a top level talent. Going from Stafford to Ryan is a downgrade, but Ryan isn't terrible as a backup QB. I plan on accepting the trade. Am I doing the right thing?

 

[SixPACK]

I give up Ahmad Bradshaw and get Cam Newton.

Romo is my starting QB, Ahdmad and McCoy my studs, followed by Beanie Wells and DeMarco Murray who had a big game for the Cowboys with. Is the hit on Bradsaw on the upgrade Newton worth it?

My WRs are Darrius Heywood-Beys, Greg Jennings, Dez Bryant, and Greg Little lol.

TE. Tony Gonzalez, who I need to get a bye week starter for him.

I'm thinking a strongly QB and a solid receiver should help solidify my team?

I would do it

I was just offered Chris Johnson and Matt Ryan for Matthew Stafford. I have been using Cam Newton as my starting QB. My RBs are Beanie Wells, Ray Rice, Peyton Hillis and Shonn Greene. I know Johnson has been a bust so far, but he is still a top level talent. Going from Stafford to Ryan is a downgrade, but Ryan isn't terrible as a backup QB. I plan on accepting the trade. Am I doing the right thing?

I honestly wouldn't. It's a 50/50 personally. You are getting another "good" RB but the QB level is way down. If you are using Newton anyway, you might as well and maybe package CJ (or another of your RB's) in a deal to get a solid WR.

 

[cavsrook25]

I honestly wouldn't. It's a 50/50 personally. You are getting another "good" RB but the QB level is way down. If you are using Newton anyway, you might as well and maybe package CJ (or another of your RB's) in a deal to get a solid WR.

My plan is to use Newton and try to turn my stable of decent backs into a solid WR. Current WRs are DeSean Jackson, Dwayne Bowe, Nate Washington and Victor Cruz. My TE is Witten.

 

[The Oi]

I would most definitely take the Ryan/CJ for Stafford deal. Wouldn't even think twice.

Ryan is going to improve and CJ is likely to break the hell out in the next 3-4 games. Stafford is definitely good, but the upside for Johnson is ridiculously high. The drop-off between Stafford and Matt Ryan playing at full capacity is not that much.

I say go for it.

 

[SanduskyCav]

Alex Smith (SF - QB)
DeMarco Murray (Dal - RB)
Dane Sanzenbacher (Chi - WR)

FOR

Matt Ryan (Atl - QB)
Mike Williams (TB - WR)
Victor Cruz (NYG - WR)


I have LeSean McCoy, Chris Johnson, Ben Tate, Murray as RBs (Start 2)
Alex Smith and Hasselback as QBs (Start 1)
Nate Washington, Heyward-Bey, Jordy Nelson, Sanzenbacher as WRs (Start 3)

I think it definitely improves me in both WR and QB categories even with the average year that Ryan is having. Is it really worth me holding on to Murray?

 

[The Voice]

Mike Williams TB sucks, I dropped his ass. Victor Cruz is good though and I'd do it just for the QB upgrade. Not sure if that RB out of Dallas is good or not.

 

[dano_24_26]

I would probably do it too. First, i'd try to see what else i could get out of murray