Should I do this trade....?

[Simon]

I get: Hakeem Nicks (NYG) + David Garrad (Jaguars)
I trade: Greg Jennings (GB) + Vince Young (TEN)

Should I do this trade? And why?

 

[kblade]

I get: Hakeem Nicks (NYG) + David Garrad (Jaguars)
I trade: Greg Jennings (GB) + Vince Young (TEN)

Should I do this trade? And why?

the difference between Garrard and Young is not enough for you to give up on Jennings. I have seen Greg in the top ten this year and I believe it. In that offense with Aaron Rodgers throwing you the ball it is always gonna be a good chance you will get a touchdown.

I say that if you are giving greg then u need to get back a better wide out. Remember if you trade any one same position for a another, in this case qb for qb and wr for wr the person you are trading with thinks they are getting the better deal. You are better off switching a position somewhere in there. Try to get an elite TE or a Better RB.

Simply this is not an upgrade for you.

good luck

 

[Simon]

the difference between Garrard and Young is not enough for you to give up on Jennings. I have seen Greg in the top ten this year and I believe it. In that offense with Aaron Rodgers throwing you the ball it is always gonna be a good chance you will get a touchdown.

I say that if you are giving greg then u need to get back a better wide out. Remember if you trade any one same position for a another, in this case qb for qb and wr for wr the person you are trading with thinks they are getting the better deal. You are better off switching a position somewhere in there. Try to get an elite TE or a Better RB.

Simply this is not an upgrade for you.

good luck

I am deciding to do this.
I have Boldin to be put in the WR slot if I do trade Jennings. I am just entertaining offers for Jennings. All I want to trade is Vince Young.

 

[Gajin]

I am deciding to do this.
I have Boldin to be put in the WR slot if I do trade Jennings. I am just entertaining offers for Jennings. All I want to trade is Vince Young.

i would strongly advice against doing this trade.
i wouldn't consider Garrard much of an upgrade over Young.

 

[bomber]

I get: Hakeem Nicks (NYG) + David Garrad (Jaguars)
I trade: Greg Jennings (GB) + Vince Young (TEN)

Should I do this trade? And why?

f*** no. Jennings is a top 6 WR. The QB's are even.

 

[Simon]

Just rejected the trade.

Thanks for the advice.

 

[kblade]

Simon who is on the waiver wire for QB's

 

[kevinoc0]

I figure we can try to make this a thread devoted to trades instead of flooding the site with constant "...trade" scenarios.

I send: Pierre Thomas
I receive: Larry Fitzgerald, Chris Cooley, Mike Tolbert/Fred Taylor (I could have either)

Here's what I have now:

I would kind of have a log jam at WRs and I'd be thin at RB, but it is a pretty enticing trade...

 

[bomber]

I figure we can try to make this a thread devoted to trades instead of flooding the site with constant "...trade" scenarios.

I send: Pierre Thomas
I receive: Larry Fitzgerald, Chris Cooley, Mike Tolbert/Fred Taylor (I could have either)


I would kind of have a log jam at WRs and I'd be thin at RB, but it is a pretty enticing trade...

I wouldn't do it. Cooley, Tolbert/Taylor are backups. They're filler. I don't trust Fitzy and DA. He gets a good amount of targets.

It will thin you out at RB(like you said). You have a good WR core in the 3 WR setup.

I would stick with your squad. It's quality.

 

[Randolphkeys]

Is there anything more overrated than wide receiver depth? Every year, I carry one or two backup receivers who I never start once... just because they are solid for thirty to forty yards every week. Quarterbacks and running backs, on the other hand, get knocked out with injuries left and right.

 

[jlj3184]

Is there anything more overrated than wide receiver depth? Every year, I carry one or two backup receivers who I never start once... just because they are solid for thirty to forty yards every week. Quarterbacks and running backs, on the other hand, get knocked out with injuries left and right.

Tell that to my ironman RB roster of Steven Jackson, Ryan Mathews and Jahvid Best.