• Changing RCF's index page, please click on "Forums" to access the forums.

2018 Trade Deadline

Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Trumbo?

Brach and Jones, okay.

Trumbo has zero place on this team.

Yup, was saying I don't think the price tag is (or should be) high for any of these guys, especially Trumbo. I'm sure any team could have all 3 for practically nothing if they were willing to pay the $9m Jones is still owed, $3m Brach is still owed, and $16m Trumbo is still owed.

He would be 4th in OPS and 5th in oWAR on this team

He's really really bad in the field though. Just no good place to put him with EE here
 
Yup, was saying I don't think the price tag is (or should be) high for any of these guys, especially Trumbo. I'm sure any team could have all 3 for practically nothing if they were willing to pay the $9m Jones is still owed, $3m Brach is still owed, and $16m Trumbo is still owed.



He's really really bad in the field though. Just no good place to put him with EE here

There really is just nowhere to hide him.

Having EE, Alonso and Trumbo on the team is tough because it’s pretty much impossible to play three at once.
 
Yup, was saying I don't think the price tag is (or should be) high for any of these guys, especially Trumbo. I'm sure any team could have all 3 for practically nothing if they were willing to pay the $9m Jones is still owed, $3m Brach is still owed, and $16m Trumbo is still owed.



He's really really bad in the field though. Just no good place to put him with EE here
That's what everyone was saying about Bruce but nobody is missing Ryder Ryan. Platoon him in RF (.855 OPS vs RHP) with one of the lefties.
 
That's what everyone was saying about Bruce but nobody is missing Ryder Ryan. Platoon him in RF (.855 OPS vs RHP) with one of the lefties.

Bruce was also a rental who was having a great year both at the plate and defensively, for his standards. Trumbo is still owed $5-6m this year and then $11m next year. That's a lot of money for a team like the Indians to absorb for a piece that's not a pressing need

I know someone said it last year with Bruce, but if Brantley-EE-Yonder-Chisenhall (obviously not guaranteed) are all healthy when the playoffs come around I think Trumbo would either be one of the last players to make the 25 man roster or be left off.
 
Sawchik excerpts:

Trading six-plus years of control of multiple promising young assets for three months of any player, even a superstar, is rarely a winning move particularly given the small sample and unpredictable nature of the postseason.

If not Machado, the ageless Adrián Beltré continues to perform at third base but he has 10-and-5 rights that allow him to block a deal. The other premier impending free agent at third base, Josh Donaldson, is nearing a return from the disabled list in Toronto, but he’s dealt with a balky shoulder all season. Toronto also could deal the versatile Yangervis Solarte, who could at least upgrade the bench over Erik González. Solarte has a 105 wRC+ for his career. Mets third baseman Todd Frazier has dealt with injury this season, but he has also retained last season’s walk-rate bump and is owed a modest $9 million next season. Perhaps the Padres would listen on Christian Villanueva. The Royals would like to move Mike Moustakas, who has become more and more a one-dimensional home run threat at third base. With so many non-contenders selling this deadline, there will be cheaper opportunities to upgrade the infield if the Indians choose to do so.

One advantage of the Indians’ significant lead in the AL Central is they can afford to experiment with young players like Díaz and Mejía if they choose to this summer.

That González is playing more often suggests the Indians are open to finding position-player upgrades. González is on pace to nearly double his playing time of a year ago at the major-league level. After playing sparingly in April — appearing in eight games and logging 12 plate appearances — he recorded 34 plate appearances and played 12 games each in May and June. While González is a defensive upgrade over Kipnis at second base, while he hit .430 in May, his true offensive talent is below league average

The outfield is arguably the greater position-player need. The problem is the outfield trade market appears to be extremely weak.

Lonnie Chisenhall’s continued lower-body injury issues make right field, at least the strong side of a platoon there, a question mark that could be addressed. One of the most intriguing options available, a resurgent Shin-Soo Choo, is owed more than $40 million, which makes his name a non-starter for the Indians unless the Rangers are willing to pick up the majority of his contract. If the Rangers did that, the prospect return would have to be significant.

Indians manager Terry Francona said late last month that Mejía, who has split his time between catcher and outfield, is not an option for the major-league outfield this season. Mejía seems reluctant to play right field where he has spent a lot of time this season in Triple A. Still, if the Indians called upon Mejía to play right, it’s hard to believe he would absolutely refuse to take the position. The greater question is whether he’d hit enough to play in a corner and overcome whatever defensive challenges he has there.

Whether the club ought to upgrade its center field options is another question.

Greg Allen remains intriguing as he has slashed .326/.429/.434 at Triple A this season despite his major-league struggles. On the other hand, Bradley Zimmer struggled upon his demotion to Triple A and is out at least four weeks with a shoulder issue. While he might be the future of the position, Zimmer probably cannot be counted upon the second half. If the Indians upgraded their infield, Kipnis is perhaps a candidate to slide to the outfield as he did late last season and into the postseason.

This author is still a believer in some club experimenting with Billy Hamilton as a type of super sub who would enter early in games as a pinch-runner and then remain in as center fielder. Hamilton is an elite baserunner and defender, he just can’t hit. But such employment would artificially enhance his on-base percentage. Hamilton scores 44 percent of the time he reaches base. The MLB average is 30 percent.
 
Biggest problem with Choo is that his defensive abilities are that of a DH at this point. It’s also the only way to keep him healthy.
 
A scout from the Tigers is at the Lake County Captains game tonight
 
A scout from the Tigers is at the Lake County Captains game tonight

Jimenez and Martin are the guys we might be interested in off the top of my head

They could also be looking at the other team for all we know.
 
With all the chatter about Mejia not wanting to play the OF and some of the recent comments made by the FO and Tito, I'm starting to come around on the idea that he could be in play at the deadline.

Maybe not for bullpen help or a rental piece-- ROI would likely be too low for a top-10 prospect-- but maybe a package for both?

I really wouldn't mind if the Indians kicked the tires on the idea of Mejia for someone like Nimmo or Conforto-- a young Major Leaguer that fits within that Lindor/Ramirez timeframe.
 
Billy Hamilton's name being brought up is interesting. I think he's more of the defense-first kind of outfielder that would fit our roster well. Allen and Davis haven't been putting up good CF numbers, or hitting.
 

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Video

Episode 3-14: "Time for Playoff Vengeance on Mickey"

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Spotify

Episode 3:14: " Time for Playoff Vengeance on Mickey."
Top