I too liked this version.Personally, I think Taker being there was the best outcome. Yeah, sure, the broken glass would have been cool, but the gong, darkness, slam, darkness and they are all gone. Couldn’t have gone better.
Quite possibly my favorite wrestling moment ever. Easily, in the last 10/15 years.
It also feels like there was a hand-off of Wrestlemania's "Final Boss" from The Dead Man to The Rock. This moment made sure everyone knew the Undertaker's legacy. No matter how much The Rock does as Wrestlemania's big bad from here on out, Undertaker will always be above him.