shoes22
Hall-of-Famer
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2012
- Messages
- 28,396
- Reaction score
- 38,875
- Points
- 148
Houston has objectively been better than us so far this season. Hell, Utah has a better point differential (before tonights game). Toronto has a similar point differential. Washington and Boston seems a little overvalued, but not egregiously so.
Beyond that, it isn't taking into account JR or Love returning to form. Smith has basically been a zero for us all year: he was bad pre injury then out for a long time. If he comes back as last year's JR, that's a huge boost, but no way for that a huge if. Similar story with Love returning to form. This is in part captured by the fact they have 2 different models. The one that was posted takes player trajectories into account, thus the Cavs get dinged for the uncertainty of Love and JR. Their outlook looks a little better when you use the model that just takes game outcomes into account and ignores player trajectories.
538's model also uses future travel as an input, and given that the Cavs a lot of future road games, their score gets dinged a bit.
Now, the Cavs real odds are probably higher because of the chill mode effect. If you are going to criticize a model for not correcting for chill mode, go right ahead.
This is true, and something I noticed when developing my own model is that 538 and a lot of the other popular season predictor models do a poor job accounting for situations where players rest or sit out games, and the models that use player stats for game projections don’t do a good enough job projecting expected minutes per game and with which lineups a player plays those minutes.
Because the Cavs haven’t played with a completely full and healthy roster since December (and their seasonal ELO projection model doesn’t account for which players will play in a game 2 weeks from now), it completely skews their projections to the point where they’re not reliable for certain teams.
Their adjusted ELO model thinks that we’ll finish the season with the same record as Boston (which may very well happen) but that Boston will get the 1 seed and also have better odds to make it out of the East than us, which is crazy.
Last edited: