The key with Bibee is to have him climb up to the top 100 lists this year so he is eligible for ROY next year in 2024 for that extra pick. Yet, I wouldn't be adverse to give some of the three a little work in September (close to 45 days and 50 innings pitched) to get their feet wet. And, if they take us late into the playoffs, it would be worth the lose of a pick.
And, I think we are going to get spoiled with our talented SP depth. I think you nailed the next group (see you left off Battenfield
). Yet, my criteria is going 6 innings for an extended period to be a solid starter (with the numbers). And, some maybe concerned about the innings limits on some guys like Morris; however, I do believe that the tribe have done some back field work after the season to get innings up that we do not know about. If you like at McK -- 83, 143, 90, none, 33 (Covid but LC work), 120, 191 (this is close to 30% of 143 5 years prior).
Cantillo was healthy until the last two years. He had abdonimal soreness in 21 and was rehabbing in August (thus would have gotten his innings in during fall work). Last year's shoulder soreness is more of a concern but didn't require injury. His innings 49, 111, Covid (but with Padres extended pool unlike McK), 13, 60. Thus, he probably could got 130ish this year (20% from 111) and then 160-170ish plus in 24. I can live with that. Thus, take him slow at the beginning of 2023 as they would any injury rehab and then see if he can be the next Morris (multi-inning guy at the end of the year in MLB). The encouraging thing before the injury was that he had 80-89 pitches in 5-6 innings for 5 starts straight. Shows that he was built up. IF he can put up his May numbers, he will climb quickly .135/.328 BA/OBP but probably unsustainable with .244 BAbip. In mid-June, he was throwing 90-91 at the beginning of the game but by the end was hitting 92 T 93 which he carried into the 5th and his last batter (coincides with working at 91-93 at MLB pipe). For comparison on the gun, Hunter started with 95/94 fastballs, so gun seems reasonable.