Should I make this trade?

[Simon]

So, my friend sent me this proposal:

I get: Steven Jackson, Mario Manningham, and Meachem

For: Vincent Jackson and Mark Ingrem

Any thoughts?

 

[Randolphkeys]

I'd do it, but I bet you can mess with his head for something a little bit better.

 

[Noonan]

Wouldn't do it. Jackson is an IR waiting to happen and Brees spreads the ball around too much.

 

[Lee]

I have a trade proposal for Ben Tate for Jordy Nelson. I get Nelson.

I have Mathews, Tolbert and Blount and Michael Bush at RB
My Wr's are Marshal, Hakeem Nicks, Mike Williams (TB) and Johny Knox

We play 2 rb's, 2 wr's and a flex.

My thought is Tate's production goes down allot when Houston's rb's get healthy. Nelson is the 2nd wr (3rd target if including TE's) in gb, but he should still be solid all year and i think Tate's production goes down.

Would you guys make this trade?

 

[The Oi]

I have a trade proposal for Ben Tate for Jordy Nelson. I get Nelson.

I have Mathews, Tolbert and Blount and Michael Bush at RB
My Wr's are Marshal, Hakeem Nicks, Mike Williams (TB) and Johny Knox

We play 2 rb's, 2 wr's and a flex.

My thought is Tate's production goes down allot when Houston's rb's get healthy. Nelson is the 2nd wr (3rd target if including TE's) in gb, but he should still be solid all year and i think Tate's production goes down.

Would you guys make this trade?

fuck yeah

 

[Noonan]

I have Tate and Foster in my league and I'm not all that sure Foster is going to be healthy for a solid stretch. You might want to hold onto Tate.

 

[Lee]

I have Tate and Foster in my league and I'm not all that sure Foster is going to be healthy for a solid stretch. You might want to hold onto Tate.

My fear is if Foster gets healthy (and Derrick Ward), Tate might not see allot of carries. if that happens, I lost on his trade value.

 

[Surge]

Simon, I'd do it in a heartbeat. Selling Meachem high and SJax while you still can. Good Trade.

Guys, give me your opinion on this one.

I just accepted it, so lets hope it works out:

I gave : Peyton Hillis, Robert Meachem
I receive: Chris Johnson, Anquan Boldin

My team post-trade: 16-team, PPR, return yard points.

QB- Vick
WR- Brandon Marshall, Santonio Holmes, Anquan Boldin
RB- Chris Johnson, Felix Jones
TE- Dustin Keller
K- Kasay (NO)
DEF- SF

Bench: CJ Spiller, Deji Karim (scored me 12 pts this week with Hillis out), Michael Bush, Arrelious Benn, Vince Young, Colt McCoy, CLE D/ST

I am 3-0 (already won, no players either team tonight), and think I just got better...

What say you?

 

[RealKingofCleve]

Simon, I'd do it in a heartbeat. Selling Meachem high and SJax while you still can. Good Trade.

Guys, give me your opinion on this one.

I just accepted it, so lets hope it works out:

I gave : Peyton Hillis, Robert Meachem
I receive: Chris Johnson, Anquan Boldin

My team post-trade: 16-team, PPR, return yard points.

QB- Vick
WR- Brandon Marshall, Santonio Holmes, Anquan Boldin
RB- Chris Johnson, Felix Jones
TE- Dustin Keller
K- Kasay (NO)
DEF- SF

Bench: CJ Spiller, Deji Karim (scored me 12 pts this week with Hillis out), Michael Bush, Arrelious Benn, Vince Young, Colt McCoy, CLE D/ST

I am 3-0 (already won, no players either team tonight), and think I just got better...

What say you?

Yeah I like that trade, nice buy low on Johnson.

 

[Shakalu M.D.]

Simon, I'd do it in a heartbeat. Selling Meachem high and SJax while you still can. Good Trade.

Guys, give me your opinion on this one.

I just accepted it, so lets hope it works out:

I gave : Peyton Hillis, Robert Meachem
I receive: Chris Johnson, Anquan Boldin

My team post-trade: 16-team, PPR, return yard points.

QB- Vick
WR- Brandon Marshall, Santonio Holmes, Anquan Boldin
RB- Chris Johnson, Felix Jones
TE- Dustin Keller
K- Kasay (NO)
DEF- SF

Bench: CJ Spiller, Deji Karim (scored me 12 pts this week with Hillis out), Michael Bush, Arrelious Benn, Vince Young, Colt McCoy, CLE D/ST

I am 3-0 (already won, no players either team tonight), and think I just got better...

What say you?

Good trade, Boldin is really underrated and Johnson is bound to turn it on eventually. I'm really anxious for it to happen, I've been really high scoring with Johnson doing diddly. I'm 3-0 and if Johnson starts playing like he should I'll be a juggernaut.

 

[Otsego Mar]

How about S-Jax, Best, & Gates for Chris Johnson? I would be receiving Johnson. I have fond memories of CJ single handedly winning me games during my 2009 championship run.

 

[ChewyOH]

So, my friend sent me this proposal:

I get: Steven Jackson, Mario Manningham, and Meachem

For: Vincent Jackson and Mark Ingrem

Any thoughts?

I wouldnt S.Jackson will get hurt Meachem production will go down when Colston comes back and not sure how good Manningham will be after Concussion. Plus i think Mark will get better.

 

[Surge]

How about S-Jax, Best, & Gates for Chris Johnson? I would be receiving Johnson. I have fond memories of CJ single handedly winning me games during my 2009 championship run.

You might be able to get Johnson for just two of those guys, which is what I would try to propose...

 

[Warren G.]

I get: Steven Jackson, Mario Manningham, and Meachem

For: Vincent Jackson and Mark Ingrem

I'd probably turn this down. Like Keys said, I think you can extract more value. Would be easier to judge with info on league scoring/active rosters.

I have a trade proposal for Ben Tate for Jordy Nelson. I get Nelson.

I wouldn't do this. I like Nelson quite a bit, but Tate's shown enough in the first few games to make me think that he'll keep getting work regardless of Foster and Ward's reliability, which I continue to have doubts about anyway. Marshall, Nicks, M.WilliamsTB, and Knox/waiver acquisition seem solid at WR to me given your league's scoring setup.

I gave : Peyton Hillis, Robert Meachem
I receive: Chris Johnson, Anquan Boldin

Think you made a good deal here, even though I'm actually 1) a little worried about CJ and 2) pretty optimistic about Hillis. Meachem for Boldin is such a strong upgrade that I think the risk of the RB swap is substantially offset.

 

[SixPACK]

How about S-Jax, Best, & Gates for Chris Johnson? I would be receiving Johnson. I have fond memories of CJ single handedly winning me games during my 2009 championship run.

I really don't know. Jackson is a complete bust so far. Usually he was good for at least 100yds/game and willl throw a TD in there every so games, but this year (granted only week 4) he is a non-factor. Best is sketchy. He has been playing really well so far (his numbers sucked last week but he had key plays to help the win). Gates is Gates.

If I was the CJ owner, I wouldnt do it even for all 3. It all depends on how his TE is doing/other RB options. If CJ is his only good one and he has 2-3 other scrubs and his TE sucks, he may.