Man, I hate when unforeseen injuries are used to call guys busts. If Rose had knee issues as a prospect, sure, call him a bust. But he had a clean bill of health, a ROY and MVP before his knees failed him. No way anyone could have seen it coming.
It's the same thing that plagued Sam Bowie, and Greg Oden. Those guys were never as good, I get that.
I don't think he was a bust as a talent at number 1, but his career, and what you project from a number player, also compared to the players that have turned out greater in that draft make him at least a borderline bust.
I was never a big Rose fan, and sure, he's definitely not in the likes of biggest busts of all-time, nor he lacked talent.
But he's 28 years old, and he's virtually untouchable. That's not a great career for a number one pick, you expect to be in their prime by now.
And even though injuries have derailed Rose. I get that, he's not the same athlete he was in his MVP stint and earlier in his career. Where I felt he was the greatest athlete we've seen see at the position.
He's still very explosive, and quicker than I'd say overwhelming most players in the league. Maybe just Wall and Westbrook are clearly more explosive, but his game is still not at an all-star level anymore, despite still having very good speed (he's still faster than Irving for example IMO, he can never stay in front of him) and explosion to play at a high level.
I think that speaks to how much skills he's always lacked in his game. When he can't rely on his next level, all-time explosion, he's just not an elite player.
His career has turn out to be pretty disappointing. I don't think he's the staple of great number one overall picks anyone should be comparing him to.
His career isn't going to be anywhere close to John Wall, or Kyrie Irving, let alone LeBron, Shaq, Duncan, Magic, and Hakeem types.