Who To Start Thread

[OhioSlayer]

Darren McFadden, Jamaal Charles

+1

 

[OhioSlayer]

Peyton Hillis, Darren McFadden, Jamaal Charles, Jonathon Stewart (DeAngelo Williams is out, so Stewart is starting today)

Who do I not start out of those 4?

I hope to God you didn't listen and picked Peyton Hillis.

 

[ohiorulez]

3 WR spots... and too many good players...

Andre Johnson vs Jags ----- or Roddy White vs Baltimore ----- or Brandon Lloyd vs KC ---- or Terrell Owens vs Indy --- or Larry Fitzgerald vs Seahawks

which 3?

 

[bcort]

Crabtree vs. StL or Woodhead vs. Pitt?

 

[jonmchugh]

should I start Big Ben or Matt Schaub or should I pick up Kyle Orton?

 

[jonmchugh]

3 WR spots... and too many good players...

Andre Johnson vs Jags ----- or Roddy White vs Baltimore ----- or Brandon Lloyd vs KC ---- or Terrell Owens vs Indy --- or Larry Fitzgerald vs Seahawks

which 3?

I would go with White, Owens and Fitzgerald.

 

[Falb7]

3 WR spots... and too many good players... Andre Johnson vs Jags ----- or Roddy White vs Baltimore ----- or Brandon Lloyd vs KC ---- or Terrell Owens vs Indy --- or Larry Fitzgerald vs Seahawks..... which 3?

Andre Johnson in a division game vs. a suspect pass defense in Jacksonville - gotta start him. White is a #1 receiver like Johnson who you have to keep in no matter what....... and Fitzgerald always plays better at home and he is also in a division game against a team he struggled against earlier this year. Go with Johnson, White, and Fitzgerald.

Crabtree vs. StL or Woodhead vs. Pitt?

Woodhead is likely to get a lot of dump offs and screens against the Steelers, and I expect Ben Jarvus Green Ellis to struggle again, giving more potential touches to Woodhead. I dont trust Troy Smith yet to give the nod to Crabtree.

should I start Big Ben or Matt Schaub or should I pick up Kyle Orton?

Schaub all the way... division game against a suspect opponent... the other 2 QBs are playing 1st place teams.

 

[bcort]

Is there any point in still having Pierre Thomas? I've held onto him, but I'm tired of him already. I know he's got a bye week, and then he might come back. I also have Reggie Bush.

Right now I'm starting Turner and Ricky Williams. I'm think about dropping Thomas finally, and adding Mike Goodson. Yay or nay?

 

[Gimme Some Mo]

Lee Evans vs Lions or Manningham vs Cowboys?

 

[CavsRules]

Normally I don't ask for much help, but considering Matt Ryan just went all Peyton Manning on my ass.. I might need a little advice.

I'm down 50 and not even half his team is done, so the quarterback position is something I need a little advice on.

I have Vick and Carson Palmer, and Vick is playing at Washington Monday night, and Palmer will be at Indy Sunday. With the Colts having a shaky defense, I was thinking maybe Palmer would do petty good.. But as of now, I'm still leaning towards Vick, who hasn't been under 40 points since I signed him.

 

[Surge]

MO- I'd go with Evans, I think he is good for a score this week.

CavsRules- Stick with Vick, and NEVER depend on Palmer.



Now to mine, I have had Josh Cribbs on my bench for a few weeks now. Is he going to get some action this week, being that he's starting at wr now? WR3 material??

 

[Gimme Some Mo]

MO- I'd go with Evans, I think he is good for a score this week.

CavsRules- Stick with Vick, and NEVER depend on Palmer.



Now to mine, I have had Josh Cribbs on my bench for a few weeks now. Is he going to get some action this week, being that he's starting at wr now? WR3 material??

I was going to go with Evans, but with Steve Smith of NYG out now, that moves Manningham to their #2, so I may go with him. Evans is also a little banged up.


I would also go with Vick (I am starting him this week as well). Can't go against him and Palmer is too inconsistent. You could play Palmer and hope for a 35-42 shootout with Indy, but Indys pass rush could also cause havoc on Palmer.

As for Cribbs, I would never play him. There has to be someone better available to go with.

 

[CavsRules]

CavsRules- Stick with Vick, and NEVER depend on Palmer.

I'm going to agree and go with Vick, but Palmer hasn't been so bad.. When Vick went down he led me to a few victories that were much needed. However, losing my past 3 and now trailing by 50, I'm going to need some spark between Sunday and Monday.

 

[Surge]

As for Cribbs, I would never play him. There has to be someone better available to go with.

Yeah, we get PR and KR yards, and return tds. So guys like Cribbs and Danny Amendola are pretty solid to have. I have used Amendola a lot this year with success, but haven't even had the confidence to try Cribbs.

He having a down year???

 

[Gimme Some Mo]

Yeah, we get PR and KR yards, and return tds. So guys like Cribbs and Danny Amendola are pretty solid to have. I have used Amendola a lot this year with success, but haven't even had the confidence to try Cribbs.

He having a down year???

I have never played in a league with PR and KR yards, so that obviously makes him more valuable. What is it, 1 pt per 10 yards?

Cribbs is having a down year in the kicking game. A lot of that has to do with teams refusing to kick him the ball though.