Ability wise, without a doubt, but when the season started, I don't think he was since he hadn't pitch above AA last season.
I really do think they (they meaning upper management) wanted him to sit another year in the minors in a lot of ways, but I am not going to complain or fight about being wrong about him being up so early since I even said in the preseason that he could be added to the 40 man roster since I felt like if injuries happened, he was going to be a factor. Honestly if Merritt, Morimando, Salazar etc didn't get hurt and were healthy and Tomlin was pitching well (though he has a 2.64 ERA since being switched to the bullpen), he wouldn't be in the pros right now. IF you agree or not, I personally don't think the plan was to have him in the pros, but all of us agree on the fact he has truly earned the right to be in the pros with the roster.
I am also looking at Happ is a veteran Lefty as well, so it's possible he could be out of the pen in the playoffs as well. I get what you are saying as well since we do have a ton of candidates from in house to fill in that 5th spot. It just depends then on if the organization trusts Plutko/Bieber to hold down the 5th spot or if they want to go with a veteran to finalize the roster. Also depends on the price since if we get him for a Ryder like we did for Bruce then I am okay with it, but if we trade a higher ranked prospect then I am not either.
So would you guys trade for a Happ if the price is low?
What would you give up for a guy like Hand from the Padres?