• Changing RCF's index page, please click on "Forums" to access the forums.

David Blatt v. Tyronn Lue

Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Anyone here that doesn't think we would have won last year with Kyrie and Kevin and RJ all available in the Finals?
Richard Jefferson or no Richard Jefferson, we would have steamrolled GSW with Kyrie and Love last year. We also had Mozgov as our beastly interior.

Post-trades we were the scariest and best team in the league and you can't convince me wouldn't have won with our whole squad intact. It was nice to avenge that loss but it still won't fully expunge that sour taste from my mouth knowing this year would have been a repeat.
 
Cavsfever, I thought I'd offer a rebuttal to your post; the conclusion there, I think, warrants a contrary viewpoint.

I think it's mostly post-championship hindsight to claim that Blatt wasn't getting the most out of our personnel and Lue was.

You may not recall, but there were many of us that were in the Blatt thread lamenting the fact that we had absolutely no semblance of an offensive system in place.

That went on for 1.5 seasons.

Definitely would not call it hindsight. Especially with people begging for him to be fired ever since the Christmas game.

In terms of record and the product on the court, the only difference between last year and this year is losing the Finals in 6 when injured vs winning the Finals in 7 when healthy.

I think we win last year too, but to suggest that's the only difference between these two teams makes no sense to me. It's not a basketball/analytical argument, but an argument that is extremely results-oriented, to a fault even. I don't think that's sufficient to really evaluate coaching talent, especially when you have this caliber of players on your team.

So just to be clear, I think it's pointless to only look at wins and losses to determine what the Cavs are doing differently with respect to coaching.

Both years, we started off wobbly at least in part due to outside factors (bad roster pre-trade last year, injury this year). Both years, we rounded into shape for the playoffs -- in fact, last year we finished stronger than we did this year, after starting a lot worse.

Again, I think you're focused far more on the wins and losses and our record, rather than what the Cavs were doing from a basketball standpoint.

Also, the Cavs played the best basketball in 2 years during the Eastern Conference run, this season.

Both years, we went 12-2 in the Eastern Conference playoffs. Then this year we won in 7 with Kyrie and Kevin (more or less) healthy, plus having Richard Jefferson. Anyone here that doesn't think we would have won last year with Kyrie and Kevin and RJ all available in the Finals?

But again, you're only looking at W-L, and not looking at anything else like the system we're running on offense. Also, we were 1 technical foul away from going down 3-1 to the Bulls.

It's really not comparable in this regard.

Now the reports from behind the scenes do indicate that Lue gets along better with the players than Blatt did, and the overall team vibe seems to be better. That's for sure.

Indeed.

But if we had lost this year then we might have heard more negativity about the team and Lue.

I understand what you're trying to say, but we can't assume the players only like Lue because we're winning; nor can we guess that there would be negative backlash against him for losing (from the players).

(I am however impressed that there were zero negative rumors from 'unnamed team sources' about dissension or negativity when we were down 0-2 and 1-3). I'm happy we have Lue, and in the end I'm sure Griffin was smarter than I / we were about promoting him in the middle of the season.

After Griffin explained the situation, I was a bit shocked by how many people questioned the decision. It seemed like some posters on RCF wanted Blatt to be the coach, even if the players vehemently disagreed. Think about that for a second -- we know better than the majority of the players on the roster? That's ridiculous.

I never understood this logic in the slightest....

But I think the moral here might be that when you have Lebron on your team and solid talent around him, then any good coach will get the job done, and both Blatt and Lue were good coaches. We sometimes over focus on coaches.

This I can't agree with.

Lue and Blatt did not do equal jobs with the same teams; Lue outcoached Blatt, period.

I don't mean to differ so strongly, but this notion that somehow it's because of LeBron, or that, Blatt is somehow this great coach and Lue just got by (not saying this is what you're saying, but.. in effect, it's fairly close to "any good coach will get the job done"); it's a false equivalence.

It does a disservice to the man who helped bring this city it's first championship in 52 years.

Let me ask you something... Why can't Lue just get props without saying Blatt is somehow as good or better than he is? It seems that folks who have supported Blatt over the years are somehow reluctant to admit Lue is the better NBA coach?

As @ACisKING also noted, this reluctance to criticize Blatt, or to jump to his defense is strange. I have never seen anything like it for any coach ever. Even right now, people trash Phil Jackson and Pat Riley daily; and they're superior coaches to David Blatt. I just cannot understand this devotion to a coach that really hasn't accomplished anything in the league.
 
Blatt benefits significantly due to the fact that most Cavs fans wanted him to be coach before he was hired. He is an unbelievably good European coach, brought certain good things to our team, and this lead to blindness in the fan base.

Was Blatt a good coach? Yeah, for sure. When Blatt was the Cavs' coach, was he the best we'd ever had? Potentially. Does Blatt deserve credit for our title? Yes, I'd say he does earn a bit. Does Blatt deserve more, or even an equal amount of credit as Lue does for winning the title? Fuck outta here. That's crazy talk. We won the championship with Lue, we didn't with Blatt, it's that simple.
 
Blatt was great. People really liked him and he was a really good coach, and got as as far as the Cavs ever had until now. People were not sure Lue was an upgrade. Easy to say now, not so easy before.

Reports that the team did not like him were countered by insiders that said it was Lebron who didn't like him. We saw history repeating as we saw with Spoelstra. Some people didn't think it was fair to fire him when the team was actually doing well. Griffin's story afterward sounded like complete bullshit. Knowing his offense was scrapped by LBJ and hearing that Mike Miller admitted this led to a lot of varied conclusions.
 
Blatt was great. People really liked him and he was a really good coach, and got as as far as the Cavs ever had until now. People were not sure Lue was an upgrade. Easy to say now, not so easy before.

Reports that the team did not like him were countered by insiders that said it was Lebron who didn't like him. We saw history repeating as we saw with Spoelstra. Some people didn't think it was fair to fire him when the team was actually doing well. Griffin's story afterward sounded like complete bullshit. Knowing his offense was scrapped by LBJ and hearing that Mike Miller admitted this led to a lot of varied conclusions.

So.. let me understand this..

The players didn't dislike him.. it was just LeBron.
Griffin was lying, and his reasoning was bullshit.
LeBron scrapped the offense, just because.. reasons..

And, conclusion, "Blatt was great, he was a really good coach, and he got the Cavs as far as anyone ever had."
 
Hold the phone, David Fucking Griffin joined a film session and jumped on LeBron for lack of effort? Man, I love griff. That guy has balls of steel and gives 0 fucks.

You can tell LeBron respects him too with some of the stories he has told.

I know this is the Lue thread, but that just jumped out at me. Griffin has been pushing the right buttons since day 1; with the biggest button of them all pressing the red button on Blatt.
 
Hold the phone, David Fucking Griffin joined a film session and jumped on LeBron for lack of effort? Man, I love griff. That guy has balls of steel and gives 0 fucks.

You can tell LeBron respects him too with some of the stories he has told.

I know this is the Lue thread, but that just jumped out at me. Griffin has been pushing the right buttons since day 1; with the biggest button of them all pressing the red button on Blatt.

Could not agree more...
 
So.. let me understand this..

The players didn't dislike him.. it was just LeBron.
Griffin was lying, and his reasoning was bullshit.
LeBron scrapped the offense, just because.. reasons..

And, conclusion, "Blatt was great, he was a really good coach, and he got the Cavs as far as anyone ever had."

You just buy whatever the reporters are selling. You keep bringing it up. The coach who got fired this year had a great record and the biggest problem you had with him was that he didn't use Love correctly. Half a year and a new coach and Love is shooting a blistering 30% from the post. Mission accomplished? Love ain't integrated, he might not ever be.

I am not going to sit here and argue that Lue is the inferior coach. That result is now carved in stone. He won, he has had more success.

You can't convince me Blatt is a bad coach either. He has had success everywhere he has been and got to the finals and won 2 games in his NBA rookie year as an NBA coach. That is damn good with a thrown together Roster and missing 2 of your 3 allstars. If you can't give him props for that... You aren't a hater? C'mon man. Hindsight bias from an outsider if I ever saw it.

I respect you, but this is the official story. If you want to be a mouthpiece for Jason Lloyd be my guest.
 
People just don't understand... LeBron James won 60+ games with Mike Brown. Mike Brown has to wear a drool bib and hire a guy to shut his mouth so a fly doesn't go in during games.

Blatt's accomplishments are diluted by LeBron. He can take anyone deep in the playoffs. Does David Blatt have a lot of basketball knowledge? Sure, but for a LeBron team, it's more about personality fit than anything. Lue added the edge to get us over the top.
 
Last edited:
You just buy whatever the reporters are selling. You keep bringing it up. The coach who got fired this year had a great record and the biggest problem you had with him was that he didn't use Love correctly. Half a year and a new coach and Love is shooting a blistering 30% from the post. Mission accomplished? Love ain't integrated, he might not ever be.

I am not going to sit here and argue that Lue is the inferior coach. That result is now carved in stone. He won, he has had more success.

You can't convince me Blatt is a bad coach either. He has had success everywhere he has been and got to the finals and won 2 games in his NBA rookie year as an NBA coach. That is damn good with a thrown together Roster and missing 2 of your 3 allstars. If you can't give him props for that... You aren't a hater? C'mon man. Hindsight bias from an outsider if I ever saw it.

I respect you, but this is the official story. If you want to be a mouthpiece for Jason Lloyd be my guest.
Lloyd, Windhorst, Haynes, McMenamin, Vardon, Steve Kyler, and Vescey all had the same story. The only person who disagreed was notorious LeBron hater, Woj. I don't know how you can say that Gour is being a mouthpiece for 95% of the entire media, some of who are on the Cavs beat (unlike Woj), and view that as a diss.

Also, I don't think Gour ever said that Blatt is a bad coach. In fact, I know he didn't. He said he wasn't the right coach for this team. That's a big difference.
 
You just buy whatever the reporters are selling.

As opposed to what? Some shit we're just going to make up because we don't like reality?

Blatt got fired because... nothing? No reason at all?? Or.. wait a minute.. cuz LeBron right?

You keep bringing it up.

I keep bringing it up anytime someone says Blatt and Lue are on equal footing. It seems weird that this keeps getting said..

Like how are they on equal footing..?

One guy got fired unceremoniously and the other guy won a championship. I can't think of any reason that Lue's accomplishments would be diminished in this way, only to support Blatt's failures. Can you help me understand why this is, because up til now, I've struggled to understand this...

Furthermore, why are you (or anyone) ignoring media reports?

Why ignore observable, reported information? And if you do choose to ignore it, then you're doing so in favor of what? What contradictory information do you have that speaks to your conclusion?

In essence, what evidence do you have to back up your supposition? Because a lot of what I read sounds like folks speaking from their own imagination rather than anything that's been reported.

The coach who got fired this year had a great record and the biggest problem you had with him was that he didn't use Love correctly.

That was one of many, but I went through a list up-thread. My post wasn't intended to re-tread all of this, but since you seem to wanna go down that road, we can add these to the list:

1) Why are you late to practice, or any team function? Why be late to depart for a road game?
2) Why are you not holding players accountable?
3) Why are you not able to figure out an offensive system that works?
4) Why don't you have control over the players and the locker-room?

Why are posters so ready to overlook these issues? Because it makes Blatt look bad? So what?

If this were Mike Brown, we'd be tearing him apart.. Why is David Blatt getting a pass?

Again, honestly, what am I missing?

Half a year and a new coach and Love is shooting a blistering 30% from the post. Mission accomplished? Love ain't integrated, he might not ever be.

Mission accomplished? Umm, maybe you haven't been keeping up with current events, but we just won the NBA Finals. We did so, largely because Lue outcoached Steve Kerr. I don't think you'd find a single commentator that would disagree with that notion.

I am not going to sit here and argue that Lue is the inferior coach. That result is now carved in stone. He won, he has had more success.

Great.

You can't convince me Blatt is a bad coach either.

I'm not trying to, I said that before.

It's like, I have to constantly say that I think Blatt is a great coach, or else.. Yes I wanted him hired over Lue, I was excited he was the coach. I never wanted him fired, and argued against it the day of. It wasn't until I heard Griffin's press conference, read the media reports, and saw how the players reacted that I realized it was the right decision.

But in this post, you're misstating my position and also calling me a "hater." So you're kind of dragging me into bashing the guy, when my point is that he doesn't deserve anywhere near the same level of credit as Ty Lue, and you do a disservice to Lue by equating the two. Lue is the superior coach on this team; period.

So to be clear, my problem is when folks say he's somehow equal or better than Lue, for.. reasons. I'm really not trying to say Blatt is a bad coach, because I don't believe that.

Or that he was undeservingly fired.. That's, well, that's frankly bullshit.

Or when they try to ignore how awful the Cavs locker room was, and whose fault that was.

Or how they'll ignore we weren't running an offensive system, at all, whatsoever.

There's so many things you are choosing to overlook, because it seems you have a preconceived notion about Blatt and how he ran the team.

What if LeBron himself told you Blatt wasn't cut out for the job, would you believe him, or no?

He has had success everywhere he has been

Except in the NBA. Except in Cleveland. Because in the NBA, he quite frankly blew his chance and now he's back overseas.

And if he's so great, why did no team pick him up? Why is he coaching in Turkey and not in the league?

You think other GMs are cool with coaches that can't manage star players, can't manage their own time, and have an irrational sense of self-accomplishment?

If we're so ready to criticize, why not criticize Blatt? Again, I keep repeating this because it seems I've never gotten an answer.. Just attacked whenever I try to speak what I think is the truth about our ex-coach.

and got to the finals and won 2 games in his NBA rookie year as an NBA coach.

Did we win those games because of him, or in spite of him?

The reporter you cited upthread says it was in spite of him.... Go figure.

That is damn good with a thrown together Roster and missing 2 of your 3 allstars.

See above.

If you can't give him props for that... You aren't a hater?

It's not about being a hater... Go through 1.5 years of posts, and find hate.

What type of shit is this anyway? I have to be "a hater" because I'm saying give credit where it's due -- and Lue deserves the credit. Don't put forward false equivalencies suggesting anyone could do it if Lue did it...

That makes me a hater?

So, if someone says Mike Brown isn't a good coach, are they a hater too? Or is it only if it's David Blatt?

C'mon man. Hindsight bias from an outsider if I ever saw it.

Do you know what hindsight bias is? Have you read my posts over the past 8 years?

I've consistently criticized EVERY Cavaliers coach.

From Mike Brown, to Byron Scott, to Brown again, to Blatt, and yes Lue.

But I've done so fairly.

My problem is that folks seem to want to praise Blatt at Lue's expense.

Just say you're a fan, you like the guy, and you wish him well -- but don't suggest that he was a good coach during his tenure with the Cavaliers... That's bullshit, and it's intellectually dishonest. If it were true, he wouldn't have been fired.

I'm sure he's a "good coach," but that doesn't describe his troubled tenure here.

I respect you, but this is the official story.

As opposed to what story? What story are you referring to that carries different facts? All these reporters are just lying?! And who is telling the truth?

I know.. let's just make some shit up, and say.. well, my truth is just as valid as theirs... Is that how this works?

If you want to be a mouthpiece for Jason Lloyd be my guest.

Fuck outta here with that... Lloyd, Windhorst (you quoted him), McMenamin, all the douches from NeoMG.. All of them were on the same page.. But me citing actual reporters makes me a "mouthpiece?"

Think about it...

I'm citing media reporters... respectable reporters.. And that makes me, according to you, a fucking "mouthpiece?!"

SMDH

Imma just let that one go bro....

You tell me who are your sources... What am I missing in your picture of the universe that lets you know that Blatt just got the shaft here and he really shouldn't have been fired for fucking up his job?
 
I Think simply adhering to what the beat writers all reported but also disregarding what this sites own insiders were reporting for quite some time is a bit disengenuous, imo. I personally think that Blatt is a great coach who was placed in a situation he didn't expect or was even remotely prepared for the minute LeBron came back. It's a shame because I think Blatt could have been a very good nba coach had the team he arrived on not the earth shattering expectations and scrutiny hoisted upon it so early in his tenure. Sadly, it would seem that the narrative around Blatt has already been established and it would surprise me if any team would want to give him another shot, nor do I think he would want to take it, any more.
 
I Think simply adhering to what the beat writers all reported but also disregarding what this sites own insiders were reporting for quite some time is a bit disengenuous, imo. I personally think that Blatt is a great coach who was placed in a situation he didn't expect or was even remotely prepared for the minute LeBron came back. It's a shame because I think Blatt could have been a very good nba coach had the team he arrived on not the earth shattering expectations and scrutiny hoisted upon it so early in his tenure. Sadly, it would seem that the narrative around Blatt has already been established and it would surprise me if any team would want to give him another shot, nor do I think he would want to take it, any more.

The site's insiders have said Windhorst and particularly Jason Lloyd are typically on point.

I don't know anything that was said in S34 that would refute anything that has been reported by McMenamin or Windhorst.
 
The site's insiders have said Windhorst and particularly Jason Lloyd are typically on point.

I don't know anything that was said in S34 that would refute anything that has been reported by McMenamin or Windhorst.

It's honestly been so long since I've thought about it, so maybe I'm misremembering things, but I seem to remember a very prominent insider on here who confirmed that LeBron was indeed trying to get Blatt fired or at the very least wasn't making Blatts job any easier. From what I've read both on here and by the beat writers I think it is absolutely true that Blatt had lost the locker room, not sure when though. I think it's safe to say that LeBron was not too happy about the hire, and Blatt was not able to erase his doubts early on, probably due to the magnitude of the situation he found himself in. I also think LeBron at some point actively campaigned for his firing in the first year, but griff told him to pipe down and get in line, so nothing was came of the matter.

ultimately my point is that Blatt is a good coach who was put in a shitty situation and I don't think he ever truly had the support of LeBron. Whet ether that was warranted or not is another discussion entirely, though.
 

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Video

Episode 3-14: "Time for Playoff Vengeance on Mickey"

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Spotify

Episode 3:14: " Time for Playoff Vengeance on Mickey."
Top