I stopped reading when you said Noam Dar isn't a good in-ring guy. Noam Dar is probably top three-four on all of 205 live. He's not a heel, that's the actual issue.
Watch Progress Chapter 14, Havoc vs Dar.
I have yet to see a match from Noam Dar that impresses me. I'd rank him damn near last of the regular 205 Live guys based on the work I've seen from him. Maybe he was good in Progress, but he's done fuck all in the WWE.
What Dar matches have you seen since he moved to the WWE that impressed you? Because to me, Neville, Alexander, Gallagher, Tozawa, Metalik, Swann, and Nese have all been clearly better. If either Gargano or Ciampo were on the show they'd be clearly better too. Even guys I've soured on like Perkins and Kendrick were at least fantastic in the CWC. Dar hasn't done a damn thing. Hell, he was so unimpressive even in the CWC that I had to actually look it up to confirm he was actually in it because I didn't remember. Apparently he wrestled Sabre and I don't even fucking recall it, and I remember Sabre had great matches with Gulak and Metalik (the latter being one of the better matches of the tournament).
I'd rank him above those two Indian dudes (although I think they've been cut from 205 Live and are solely NXT jobbers now), Daivari (who has been even more bland and forgettable than Dar), and HoHo Lun (who should have been released if he hasn't been already). Maybe Lince Dorado too, but he was also better in the CWC. That's about it. Mustafa Ali is a close one. I think he has more potential than Dar, but he hasn't really been given a chance to showcase himself yet.
By the way, I think my main issue with Dar is that, like Daivari, he works a bland, generic style on a show that has been killed by guys working bland, generic styles. 205 Live should embrace its inner lucha and showcase athletic, flippy matches that separate it from the stuff you see on Raw and Smackdown. What's the point of having a division of lightweights if they wrestle the same fucking style as the heavyweights? 205 Live should feature fast-paced, exciting matches that are different from what you see from main roster matches. And while guys like Gallagher and Gulak don't exactly fit within that mold, they work a highly entertaining style of their own and are more than capable with working great matches with the hyper-athletes like Alexander.