Thanks for the replies, guys. I called Fidelity, and they helped me out. They said that my contributions are based on my gross pay, so I am paying 5% of my pay BEFORE taxes. That amount I am contributing would stay the exact same if I were contributing to a traditional 401k. Thus the employee contribution stays the same no matter what because there is no differing amount to contribute off of since the amount I contribute stays the same in both scenarios.
For the Roth 401k, I don't get to reduce my claimed incone at the end of the year, whereas, with the traditional 401k, I do, but I get taxed when the money comes out. My employer's contributions are put in the traditional way no matter what.
However, I did think of an interesting topic today. So many articles and forums discuss the merits of contributing to a 401k while in debt, but not many talk about whether a Roth 401k is better than a traditional 401k while in debt. For example, we all know that a dollar today is worth more than a dollar in the future. If one is paying off debt that has interest on it, then delaying the tax until a later time by choosing a traditional 401k could let them get out of debt faster, thus saving money on interest. It's never a guarantee that taxes will be higher in the future. Besides, one can always start contributing to a Roth 401k once they get out of debt so that only a small portion of their 401k is taxed on the way out. Normally, I'd say that a Roth 401k would be better, but, because of the immediate cash flow produced by contributing to a traditional 401k (up to the company match and no more if you're in debt), that might the the better option in the long run.
And
@natedagg, I have been thinking about doing a part-time training job on the side. I have been training on and off for about 5 years now, and it might be time to start again. I'm in the green right now month-by-month, but it's not by much, so getting out of credit card debt on top of school loans has been slow, not to mention wanting to get a house (although my mother and father in law have agreed to do the remaining amount on a downpayment on a house of whatever we can't save up and we just pay them back, which is super nice). It gets tougher when I live in the greater Seattle area and rents/bills are going up more than my and my wife's pay. So clawing to save money and reinvest more wisely is at the forefront of my thoughts all the time so that I can gain financial freedom.
I've been doing tons of research lately on how each dollar saved now is going to be essentially worth as much as 10x or even more if wise investing is involved, so it really changes how one thinks about money. In light of this, I've done just about everything imaginable to try to save money.
Just in the past year, I've changed car insurances twice, increased my deductible, took advantage of low interest rate balance transfer offers on two different credit cards, consolidated some credit card debt by taking a secured loan out via my wife's car, deferred all of my school loan payments, switched renter's insurance, opened a credit card with only 6.9% interest rate (permanent rate, and no balance transfer or cash advance fees!) that required that I close another card in order to get this one (but I called the card that got closed and had them reopen it anyway!), and now I'm looking to move to save a couple hundred dollars a month in rent. I'm also going to refinance the private student loans I have as well as refinance both car loans I have to lower interest rates that I just got offered from a local credit union.
My wife and I also rarely go out to eat or do anything that costs money (maybe once a month), and we never buy anything we don't need or for ourselves unless it's for a holiday or birthday.
This kind of stuff isn't fun, but it's necessary in order to get to where I want to be. One thing I'm really riding on in terms of turning my wife's and my future around is getting promoted. When I had originally interviewed at my current workplace, they were going to put me immediately in at store manager position, but the HR manager overrode the district manager's wishes and put me in as an assistant manager despite how I had been a store manager before. Now I am getting closer to getting promoted after basically two fucking years. I am about to enter into our store manager training program in August and should be ready to accept any store by November. We'll see what my employer offers me if it gets to the point where they offer me that position, but, if they offer me what I think is fair (about 14k more a year).
Once we get out of credit card debt, it will allow us to apply for a mortgage loan with a good interest rate due to an improved credit score (currently around 680). We're going to do a 30-year loan because the research shows that reinvesting the saved money each month from paying less to the loan will yield 10s of thousands of dollars more in the end than doing a 15-year mortgage. You also get tax breaks on the interest you pay, which mitigates some of the costs of the additional interest from a longer mortgage with a slightly higher interest rate. There's a reason why Quicken Loans and other places are pushing for 15-year mortgages. It's simple math that getting 7-15% annual returns on the stock market is going to beat out a tax deductible mortgage interest rate of 4-5% and that putting tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars toward one's retirement earlier on as opposed to after a house is paid off is going to end up in a bigger retirement fund in the end.
Sorry for a long-winded update on my financial situation and going on from topic to topic. My wife HATES talking about finances, so, beyond her salary, I'm kinda slugging out this financial battle alone and have on one else to talk to about it. So it's nice to talk about my current financial state here, hear feedback, and talk about different theories on finances.
TL;DR version:
- Turns out my contribution is based off of my gross pay, so my contribution and my company's match stay the same for both Roth and Traditional 401k
- Although Traditional 401k may not be the best for tax savings in the end, going that route if one is in credit card debt can help one get out of debt more quickly and save on interest due to the yearly, immediate tax savings
- Living with as low of costs as possible and saving that money for retirement while still young can yield 10x or more per dollar saved in the early years of investing. Do everything you can to save or at least be informed when you do spend. Don't settle for high interest on your debts or high rent.
- Life is a rat race, especially for a renter. Buy a house ASAP to get out of throwing away money through renting. And, when you do buy a house, go for the 30-year mortgage. Studies show that reinvesting the saved money from paying less on the mortgage each month will yield tens if not hundreds of thousands more over the course of one's life.