• Changing RCF's index page, please click on "Forums" to access the forums.

Cleveland Indians 2018-2019 Offseason Outlook

Do Not Sell My Personal Information
True Blue LA:

Dodgers 2018 top prospects: No. 3, Alex Verdugo

No player in the top 20 of this year’s Dodgers prospect list has featured in as many of my prospect lists as Alex Verdugo, and that speaks to his consistent and steady climb up the organizational ladder. Seen by some prognosticators as a better pitching prospect than hitting prospect as an amateur, Verdugo has shown the best hit tool in the organization since Corey Seager graduated to the major leagues. Though just 21 on opening day, Verdugo needs to show more power to feature as an impact center fielder, and the competition for roster spots in the Dodger outfield is as competitive as ever.

With the smoothest hands and quickest trigger in the organization, Verdugo generates some of the easiest contact you will see at the minor league level. He has exceptional pitch recognition and the willingness to go with pitches on the outer half if need be, making him increasingly tough to strike out, having done so in just 10% of appearances last year. Verdugo’s discipline at the plate shows itself less in his walk rate and more in his ability to drive the ball from foul line to foul line depending on the pitch.

While he’s worked to add more loft to his swing, Verdugo still lags behind other system outfielders in power. He had just six home runs in Triple-A last season and his career isolated slugging is just .128 across over 1,600 at bats. His lack of power likely stems more from approach than in any physical inability. Because contact comes easily for Verdugo, he’s often inclined to just put the ball in play rather than look for something to pull or lift.

Alex Verdugo
Position: CF/RF
2018 rank: 3
2017 rank: 4
How acquired: 2014 draft (2nd rd)
2017 stats: .314/.389/.436, 27 2B in AAA
2017 highest level: MLB
2018 age: 22

Verdugo could make some adjustments to his swing to add power. He has added more loft to his swing since playing in Tulsa, with a plane a little closer to matching the pitch plane. His extension is fine given his 6’0 frame, but his swing can occasionally be over-rotational with less force being exerted back toward the pitch. I’m sure the team has been loathe to make too many adjustments to Verdugo’s swing given how strong his hit tool is at present.

Despite lacking tremendous foot speed, Verdugo has been able to hold centerfield for most of his minor league career. He takes good routes to balls and generally is quick to move on balls in the gap. He has a strong and accurate arm that could handle the demands of right field if needed. Verdugo is a solid athlete and fluid mover, but he has produced little in terms of speed production on the base paths.

At 6’0 and 205 lbs., Verdugo is likely finished filling out his frame. He’s not as overly reliant on his physical tools as other prospects in the system, but is a more instinctive player that shouldn’t worry about slowing tools as he matures. Still, the Dodgers likely wonder just how much more development they can coax out of him.

In most other organizations, Verdugo likely would have broke Spring Training with the big league club, and he’s capable of holding down a starting role now. However, the roster crunch cost Los Angeles another talented outfielder in Trayce Thompson and Verdugo’s chance to make the roster was notional at best. As a member of the 40-man roster, though, Verdugo will likely get a few opportunities to stick when injuries and ineffectiveness eventually arise.

While Verdugo’s hit tool gives him a high floor, it’s still a question as to how high his ceiling might be. A future as a Quad A or fourth outfielder is still a possibility given his lack of game power and suitability for center field long term. However, he still has the bat speed and strength to develop average pop with more commitment to plate adjustments.

Given the outfield crowdedness and Verdugo’s readiness as a prospect, his greatest value to the Dodgers in 2018 could come in trade, where he’s got the reputation to be the prospect centerpiece of a significant haul. Barring trade, I still see Verdugo’s best case scenario is that of a Nick Markakis-style corner outfielder, with elite prospect worthy peak seasons, and the contact skills for longevity, but ultimately a ceiling as a second division starter.
Important to note that this report was prior to last season. He showed more power by hitting 10 HR in 91 AAA games.

In all honesty, hitting-wise, he's very Brantley-esque. He does bring a plus arm to the OF, but despite his success in the minors, I'd still project him more into RF than CF.
 
I just don't know that Verdugo is the ceiling you look for when dealing a Corey Kluber.

He's going to be a very good player, probably above league average. But is he going to be a 4-5 WAR player consistently? I don't know that I see that.

To me, so much depends on the rest of the package and if the Indians re-invest Kluber's salary or pocket it.
 
Which is said about a lot of other prospects. I remember when big red thunder Clint Frazier was an elite prospect too.

If I'm dealing Kluber I want Bellinger and won't back down. LA could sign a big OF bat whenever they want and thats what I'll tell them.

You're acting like Frazier is a bust? He's been solid in what little time he's gotten in NY. It's not an indictment on him that he hasn't cracked the Yankee OF.

I certainly want more high-end value than Verdugo in a Kluber deal, but he's also a very different prospect than Frazier. Verdugo had more walks than strikeouts as a 21 year old in AAA. He's an incredibly advanced hitter, nobody ever said that about Frazier.
 
I'd lose my mind if we trade Kluber for a prospect. I understand where there's smoke, there's fire... so he's likely gone, him or Bauer rather, but please not for a prospect. These dudes are worth MLB ready players.
 
I'd lose my mind if we trade Kluber for a prospect. I understand where there's smoke, there's fire... so he's likely gone, him or Bauer rather, but please not for a prospect. These dudes are worth MLB ready players.

One specific name gets mentioned and now all the sudden that’s the package?

If a deal goes down, for both the short term and long term, it would be more than just Verdugo
 
You're acting like Frazier is a bust? He's been solid in what little time he's gotten in NY. It's not an indictment on him that he hasn't cracked the Yankee OF.

I certainly want more high-end value than Verdugo in a Kluber deal, but he's also a very different prospect than Frazier. Verdugo had more walks than strikeouts as a 21 year old in AAA. He's an incredibly advanced hitter, nobody ever said that about Frazier.
No, I just don't think Clint is elite like we all initially thought, or else he'd cracked that OF and solidified his spot.
 
I'd lose my mind if we trade Kluber for a prospect. I understand where there's smoke, there's fire... so he's likely gone, him or Bauer rather, but please not for a prospect. These dudes are worth MLB ready players.

If it makes you feel any better, Verdugo would definitely be starting from day 1 in the majors.
 
One specific name gets mentioned and now all the sudden that’s the package?

If a deal goes down, for both the short term and long term, it would be more than just Verdugo

Verdugo headlining a package is what upsets me, then followed by those other minor leaguers.
 
No, I just don't think Clint is elite like we all initially thought, or else he'd cracked that OF and solidified his spot.

Depends on your definition of elite, but I don't think anybody ever saw him as an Acuna, Bryant, Harper, elite prospect. Plus, the guy is only 24. I'd still anticipate a good long career with some potential AS appearances for him.
 
If it makes you feel any better, Verdugo would definitely be starting from day 1 in the majors.
It'll make me feel better if we get Bellinger. Fuck LA. They'll be getting rich because they have no use for Verdugo, hence why their top prospect is getting dangled for a very good SP.
 
I see a lesser Michael Brantley...
 
The Indians would be getting quite a bit more than just Verdugo in terms of additional prospects and another MLB bat (Joc, Puig) one would presume.
 
If that’s the headlining return in a Kluber deal let’s just keep him
Fan rumor parameters on another board:

Verdugo, Joc Pederson, Dustin May and/or other prospect for Kluber/Kipnis.

Indians would “gain” 28-30M in salary relief in that deal which if redistributed would allow us to add some quality players.
 

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Video

Episode 3-15: "Cavs Survive and Advance"

Rubber Rim Job Podcast Spotify

Episode 3:15: Cavs Survive and Advance
Top